Questions:

What was your first impression of this site?
How does this site organize the flow of information? (Do they have links on the left and text on the right? Some other scheme? No scheme?)
Does the site structure make sense or does it confuse you? Why?
Does the site graphics/layout/multimedia enhance the site or detract from it? Why?
How long did it take for the home page to load? Was the load time reasonable?
Was the text color and size readable? If a background color or image was used, did it enhance or detract from the site?
Did the site have a navigation bar or other navigation tool? Was the navigation well done?
Did the site have a color scheme or look and feel that was repeated on all the pages?
How does the site respond to smaller window sizes (responsive design)?
What does this site offer that was unusual or very well done?

Answers:

I like the way everything is placed, it looks very cute and seasonal.
The site is very well organized and everything was easy to find.
It's pretty straight forward and I feel like anyone could find what there looking for fast.
I think the designs add the page. It doesn't add any confusion and helps them appeal to there target audience.
It took no time, very fast and efficient.
It's all very complimentary and looks put together.
Yes it had a navigation bar on the left with words as well as pictures to make it easy to use.
They use red and light yellow, which are analogous and look good together.
It cuts off some parts rather than just shrinking them.
They have a recipe page and most look yummy. There are some weird ones like fish taco's, but maybe I just think it's weird since I don't like fish.